Skip to main content

Equal-ish? How the 14th Amendment Became a Civil Rights MVP

Spoiler: It wasn’t just about citizenship—it’s the secret sauce behind a lot of modern justice.

If the U.S. Constitution were a movie cast, the 14th Amendment would be the unsung hero who shows up halfway through the film and saves the day. It may not have the star power of the 1st or 2nd Amendments, but behind the scenes? It’s working overtime—powering everything from school desegregation to same-sex marriage.

Let’s unpack this civil rights heavyweight: where it came from, what it does, and why it keeps showing up in Supreme Court blockbusters.

The Fight for America - 14th Amendment citizen Sticker

Where It All Started: A Post-Civil War Makeover

Picture it: 1868. The Civil War is over, slavery is abolished (thanks, 13th Amendment), and America is trying to figure out what "freedom" actually means. Into this legal chaos walks the 14th Amendment.

Here’s what it brought to the table:

  1. Citizenship for All – If you’re born or naturalized in the U.S., congratulations, you’re a citizen! (Looking at you, formerly enslaved people.)

  2. Due Process – The government can’t take your life, liberty, or property without a fair process. No kangaroo courts allowed.

    *Kangaroo court: an unofficial court held by a group of people in order to try someone regarded, especially without good evidence, as guilty of a crime or misdemeanor.  

  3. Equal Protection – States must treat people equally under the law. No playing favorites.

Sounds simple, right? Plot twist: it took decades—and a lot of court fights—to make those guarantees actually mean something.

Brown v. Board of Education (1954): Equality Goes to School

If you remember one 14th Amendment case from school, it’s probably this one.

Back in the day, schools were “separate but equal.” Spoiler: they were definitely separate but absolutely not equal. In Brown v. Board, the Supreme Court used the Equal Protection Clause to strike down racial segregation in public schools.

This wasn’t just about classroom seating charts. It was a game-changer—a legal green light for the entire civil rights movement.

Bonus: It’s also a rare case where the Supreme Court changed its mind (cough Plessy v. Ferguson cough). Growth!

Obergefell v. Hodges (2015): Love is Love (and Constitutional)

Fast forward to 2015. Same-sex couples across the country were saying, “Hey, equal protection means we get to marry too.” And the Supreme Court agreed.

In Obergefell, the Court ruled that denying same-sex couples the right to marry violated both Equal Protection and Due Process under the 14th Amendment. Boom—marriage equality, coast to coast.

The decision recognized that dignity, freedom, and equality aren’t limited to straight couples. The 14th Amendment had once again stepped in like a lawyered-up fairy godparent.

Roe v. Wade, and Then Dobbs: Privacy, Revisited

You can’t talk 14th Amendment without mentioning Roe v. Wade (1973), which used the Due Process Clause to protect a woman’s right to choose.

But plot twist: in 2022, Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization overturned Roe, saying the Constitution doesn’t guarantee that right. Still, the decision debated the scope of the 14th Amendment extensively—and signaled that debates over due process and bodily autonomy are far from over.

So while Roe is out, the 14th is still the legal turf on which these rights are argued.

The Magic of “Substantive Due Process” (Wait, Don’t Leave!)

Okay, yes, “substantive due process” sounds like something you’d hear in a very boring courtroom drama—but stick with me. It’s the idea that the government can’t just follow proper procedures when messing with your rights—it also can’t mess with certain fundamental rights at all, unless it has a really good reason.

Things like:

  • Raising your kids how you want

  • Marrying who you love

  • Using contraception

  • Choosing your healthcare

These all come from the idea that the 14th Amendment protects more than just paperwork—it protects personal liberty. It’s like the Constitution saying, “Hey, don’t just technically follow the rules. Be cool.”

Modern Fights: Gender, Trans Rights, Disability Access & More

The 14th Amendment isn’t stuck in the past—it’s still the go-to tool in civil rights lawsuits today.

  • Trans rights: Advocates argue that trans individuals deserve equal treatment under laws like Title IX and Equal Protection.

  • Gender equality: The courts have used the 14th to strike down laws that treat women unfairly, like Virginia’s once-all-male military academy.

  • Disability rights: While the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is the main law, Equal Protection arguments are sometimes used when states don’t provide access or accommodations.

It's not just a dusty old clause—it’s the legal Swiss Army knife of fairness.

Wait, What Can’t It Do?

As powerful as it is, the 14th Amendment isn’t a magic wand. Courts still interpret its clauses pretty conservatively at times, and not every case invoking it ends in progress. It also doesn’t automatically fix inequality in the real world—laws help, but action, policy, and (yes) voting still matter a ton.

And let’s not forget: the Equal Rights Amendment—which would explicitly guarantee gender equality—still hasn’t made it into the Constitution. That’s how incomplete the equality story still is.

Final Thoughts: The Most Misunderstood MVP

The 14th Amendment is kind of like that friend who quietly shows up, helps you move apartments, fights for your rights in court, and never asks for gas money. It's powerful, flexible, and always down to fight for fairness—even when the rest of the country is being... well, less than fair.

So next time you hear a Supreme Court case being debated on the news, listen for those magic words: Equal Protectionand Due Process. Odds are, the 14th Amendment is somewhere in the mix—dusting off its legal briefs and stepping into the ring once again.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Eight Amendment

  The Eighth Amendment: Protecting You from Cruel and Unusual Punishment When it comes to fairness and justice, the Eighth Amendment plays a major role in making sure the punishment fits the crime. While it might not always grab the headlines, it’s a critical part of ensuring that punishment in the U.S. is humane and proportional. Let’s explore why this amendment matters. What Does the Eighth Amendment Say? The Eighth Amendment reads: “Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.” In simpler terms: The government can’t set unreasonably high bail amounts or fines. You can’t be subjected to cruel or unusual punishment. Why It’s So Crucial The Eighth Amendment is all about keeping things fair and humane, even when people are being punished for crimes. Here’s why it’s so important: No Excessive Bail or Fines : The Eighth Amendment prevents the government from charging unfairly high bail or fines. It ensures that people ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Tenth Amendment

The Tenth Amendment: States vs. Uncle Sam The Constitution’s Tenth Amendment is all about setting boundaries. It’s not flashy, but it’s foundational to how power is divvied up in the U.S. Let’s dive into what it says and why it matters. The Tenth Amendment states: “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.” This amendment is  all about dividing power between the federal government and the states. The gist is simple: if the Constitution doesn’t give a specific power to the federal government, and it’s not explicitly denied to the states, then the states or the people get to call the shots. Mini Lesson on Federalism: Federalism is the separation of powers between state and federal government. In the very first constitution (the Articles of Confederation), almost all of the power was given to the individual states while little-to-no power was given to the federal gov...
Post a Comment
Read more

Seventh Amendment

  The Seventh Amendment: Your Right to a Jury in Civil Cases You’ve probably heard about juries in criminal cases, but did you know that the Seventh Amendment ensures you have the right to a jury trial in certain civil cases too? This amendment might not get as much attention as some of the others, but it’s an important part of ensuring fairness in legal disputes. Let’s break it down and see why this right is so essential. What Does the Seventh Amendment Say? The Seventh Amendment states: “In suits at common law, where the value in controversy shall exceed twenty dollars, the right of trial by jury shall be preserved, and no fact tried by a jury shall be otherwise re-examined in any Court of the United States, than according to the rules of the common law.” In simpler terms: If you’re involved in a civil case where the amount in question is more than $20, you have the right to a jury trial. Once a jury decides the facts of the case, those facts can’t be overturned by a judge, excep...
Post a Comment
Read more